|
Tube
Selection for Analyzer Sample Systems
Selecting the right process tube for use in analyzer sample transport
systems requires critical considerations of process and application
conditions. There are a wide variety of metallic and non-metallic
tube types available: welded and seamless 304 and 316 series stainless
steel, other metallurgies used are Monel®, Hastelloy®, Inconnel®,
Incoloy®, zirconium, Super-Duplex, titanium, and even copper.
Common non-metallic tube materials are Teflon® (PFA, PFE, and
PTFE fluoropolymer), polyethylene and Halar (ECTFE). Some bundles
may also contain coaxial tubing (tube-in-tube) or unheated tubes
for calibration gas and blowback lines.
OBrien Analytical also provide a wide variety of in-house
services including electropolishing and chemical passivation as
well as thermocouple cleaning and cleaning for oxygen service. We
also furnish fused silica lined process tubes. (see
tubing product classifications)
Improper
tube selection may lead to a failed analyzer systems caused by adsorption,
contaminants in the tube, corrosion stress cracking or gas permeation.
Restricted sample flow, long sample lag times, and kinking are also
problems often related to tube selection.
Selecting
Tube Material
Consider the porosity, corrosion, and adsorption as well as the
size and metallurgy (or composition) of the tubing.
Porosity
Fluoropolymer tubes are common for many analyzer applications particularly
stack gas measurement. For all of its positive characteristics fluoropolymer
is porous and has a limited working pressure, which
deteriorates rapidly as temperature increases. Consider using only
thick wall (0.062 / 1.5mm) tubing.
If the porosity and / or pressure rating is not acceptable then
consider using electropolished or fused silica lined stainless steel
tube. While resistant to most chemicals fused silica (consider it
the same as glass) has limited resistance to acids so caution should
be exercised.
Corrosion
When you check for corrosion resistance it is imperative that you
design for failure. Just because the process stream does not contain
acids under normal conditions you need to determine the component
concentrations and byproducts if an upset occurs. The creation of
acids is common in stack gas applications when inadequate heating
allows water vapor to condense and combine with sulfur or nitrogen
compounds.
Adsorption
When utilizing stainless steel tubing this phenomenon will exhibit
itself in the measurement of trace amounts of component (especially
moisture and sulfur compounds, H2S and SO2.) The structure of commercial
stainless steel tubing is such that compounds may be caught up in
the crevices and not reach the analyzer. Once the tube
is saturated the levels will equalize relative to the process as
long as the process composition, temperature and pressure remain
constant. Any change in composition, temperature or pressure may
cause compounds to be adsorbed more by the tube or release from
the tube surface and spike the sample to the analyzer.
As a result adsorption / desorption creates inconsistent and unpredictable
results. This is sometimes referred to as the memory effect.
This problem can often be solved by the use of electropolished or
fused silica lined tubing.
|
TUBE
|
GENERAL
USES
|
CHARACTERISTICS
|
| Commercial
316L Seamless SS |
Standard
instrument tubing. Free Fe will react with most acids. |
Improved surface roughness
Limitations:
Limited by chemical reactivity and oxygen levels
Subject to stress corrosion cracking.
High Ra values of internal surface contribute to adsorption
/ desorption problems.
Advantages:
Inexpensive and readily available. |
| Commercial
316L Welded SS |
Standard
low pressure / temperature instrument tubing.
Free iron will react with most acids. Weld containments may
contribute to reduced corrosion protection compared to seamless
tubing. |
Improved surface roughness
Limitations:
Limited by chemical reactivity and oxygen levels
Subject to stress corrosion cracking.
Pressure rating less than seamless products.
May be more susceptible to corrosion than seamless products.
Advantages:
Inexpensive and readily available. |
| Fluoropolymer
(Teflon®) |
Low
pressure sample and chemical lines where 316 SS is not acceptable.
Used for applications requiring cleanliness. |
Surface
Roughness: NA
Limitations:
Limited by chemical reactivity and oxygen levels.
Temperature and pressure limits vary by variety of fluoropolymer.
Very permeable. Used for manufacture of permeable membranes.
Advantages:
Excellent chemical resistance.
Flexible. |
| TrueTube CP |
Applications
requiring additional cleanliness or corrosion resistance compared
to commercial SS tube. |
An
OBrien Analytical Product
Chemically polished 316L SS seamless tubing.
Improved surface roughness
Limitations:
Limited by chemical reactivity and oxygen levels.
Advantages:
Enhanced Cr/Fe and CrO/FeO ratios improve chemical resistance.
Improved adsorption / desorption characteristics compared to
commercial tubing. |
| TrueTube
EP |
Critical
sample systems where adsorption / desorption is a problem. |
An
OBrien Analytical Product
Electropolished and chemically treated 316L SS seamless tubing.
Improved surface roughness
Limitations:
Limited by chemical reactivity and oxygen levels.
Advantages:
Cr/Fe ratio better than 1.5:1 and CrO/FeO ratio better than
3:1 improve chemical resistance.
Improved adsorption / desorption characteristics compared to
commercial tubing. |
| TrueTube
FS |
Moderately
acid samples and sulfur. |
An
OBrien Analytical Product
A secondary fused silica coating applied to chemically polished
316L SS tubing.
Surface Roughness: NA
Limitations:
Very poor resistance to bases.
Reacts adversely with fluorides.
Advantages:
Has improved chemical resistance over substrate alone.
Can be used at higher temperatures than polymer coatings.
Covalently bonded matrix which reduces surface tension.
Has found wide acceptance for transporting sulfur samples. |
|